Hermes stands as a premier luxury brand renowned for its timeless products crafted in irresistibly attractive designs. The brand's handbags have become highly sought after by fashion enthusiasts and affluent women who value their appearance and the accessories they choose. This admiration stems from the unparalleled craftsmanship that goes into each bag, taking 48 hours to complete, along with the use of the finest raw materials.
For many women, owning even a single Hermes handbag symbolizes style, elegance, and opulence. Hermes offers an array of sophisticated yet trendy bags, including the Kelly, Birkin, Constance, Jypsiere, Herbag, and Evelyn, each with its unique charm.
Among these, the Kelly and Birkin bags stand out as the most desired. However, if your budget permits the purchase of only one, you may find yourself in a quandary given these luxurious handbags often command six-figure prices. Furthermore, if you lack familiarity with the distinctions between the two, investing in an Hermes bag without proper knowledge could result in acquiring one that remains unused, as each bag complements different styles.
Therefore, let’s delve into a comparison of both bags to determine which one would harmonize best with your wardrobe. Additionally, if you're considering other options, you might want to explore the differences between the Louis Vuitton Neverfull MM, GM, and PM models as well.
The History of Hermes
Interestingly, Hermes initially did not emerge as a handbag brand. Established in 1837 by Thierry Hermes, this small enterprise specialized in crafting high-quality harnesses, saddles, and bridles for horses, gaining acclaim for their luxurious saddles during that era.
In 1920, Hermes ventured into the world of high-end bags with its first handmade offering. The brand introduced the Sac A Depeches in 1935, which Princess Grace Kelly frequently carried, as its spacious design allowed her to discreetly conceal her pregnancy. Consequently, the bag was renamed in her honor.
Fast forward to 1984, when Jean Louis Dumas, then chief executive at Hermes, shared a flight with actress Jane Birkin. After her bag broke during the journey, the two engaged in a discussion about the ideal bag, ultimately leading to the creation of the iconic Hermes Birkin.
Comparing the Hermes Kelly and Birkin: Which Bag is Right for You?
1. Variants
The Hermes Kelly bag boasts a wide array of variants. The primary two include the Hermes Kelly Retourne and Hermes Kelly Sellier, differentiated by their stitching styles. The Retourne features hidden seams with rounded edges, crafted from soft leather, giving it a more relaxed and casual appearance.
In contrast, the Hermes Kelly Sellier utilizes firmer leather, showcasing visible seams and defined edges, resulting in a more structured aesthetic. The Kelly line also offers several sizes, ranging from 15 to 50, with the 25, 28, and 35 being the most popular options.
The Birkin bag presents two variants based on its hardware design, incorporating options for a lock and key, zipper, and metal feet. The hardware choices include an 18-karat gold-plated version and one finished with palladium. The Birkin line features five size options: 20, 25, 30, 35, and 40, with the 25 being the most sought after and the 20 being a limited edition release.
2. Dimensions
Let's examine how the dimensions of Hermes bags vary regarding size and shape.
Shape
The shape of the bags is one of their most significant differences. The Kelly displays a sharply defined trapezoidal structure, characterized by angular margins, straight-cut sides, and a neatly shaped top flap. It includes a single handle ideal for shoulder carrying, a flap closure with a lock and key, and a long strap that allows for cross-body use.
Conversely, the Birkin is more casual and lacks a rigid formality, resembling a tote with its square shape, dual straps, a changeable flap closure that permits an open or closed option, and softly curved edges and top.
Size
In terms of sizes, the Kelly bag is typically available in six options, measuring 25 cm, 28 cm, 32 cm, 35 cm, 40 cm, and 50 cm in length. Its height ranges from approximately 19 to 25 cm, and the width varies between 9 and 12 cm based on the bag's length.
On the other hand, Birkin bags are larger, offering four primary sizes: 25 cm, 30 cm, 35 cm, and 40 cm. Their heights range from 20 cm to 30 cm, and widths encompass 13 cm to 21 cm, respectively.
3. Bag Components
Next, let’s explore the individual components that differentiate the Kelly and Birkin bags.
Handles
The Kelly bag features a single handle on top, enabling a chic carry or an elegant arm hold for special occasions. Additionally, it includes a detachable long strap that facilitates cross-body use, allowing for hands-free convenience.
In contrast, the Birkin bag is equipped with two longer handles and lacks a long strap, limiting it to handbag use. Notably, the handles on both bags are made from leather.
Front Flaps
Both bags are adorned with front flaps that feature the classic Hermes buckle along with a lock and key closure. Due to the single handle on the Kelly, its flap must be closed during use. Conversely, the Birkin bag’s upper slits are well-finished, allowing the front flap to be pushed inside, transforming it into an open tote bag.
Accessories
Each bag includes turrets for the locks, a leather clochette bell to conceal the keys, D-rings for strap attachment, a tight loop around the handle to connect the clochette, and various colors to enhance their appeal.
The key distinction is that the Kelly bag comprises two pairs of D-rings—one extra for the long strap—while the Birkin is equipped with a Pontet, a metal bracket designed to keep the singles in place.
4. Style
The style of both bags is markedly different. The Kelly was designed for women of sophistication and grace who wish to maintain an elegant appearance regardless of the occasion. With its well-defined shapes and sharp designs, the Kelly bag epitomizes refinement.
In contrast, the Birkin bag conveys a more relaxed vibe, catering to women who prefer a laid-back approach, allowing them to carry everything they need without concern for the bag’s shape. Therefore, Birkin bags are synonymous with a more casual attitude compared to the meticulously maintained Kelly bags.
